The quarterback debate in Pittsburgh is intensifying as the NFL Draft approaches, with experts divided on how to navigate the lingering shadow of Aaron Rodgers. Dan Orlovsky remains confident that Rodgers will return for another season following a successful 2025 campaign, but he cautions the organization against complacency.
Orlovsky also argues that Ty Simpson is a blue-chip talent who warrants first-round consideration in any draft class and should be aggressively pursued to learn behind Rodgers.
On the other hand, team insiders like Brooke Pryor suggest that the front office is emphasizing physical traits suited for cold-weather football, such as hand size and arm length. This focus might lead them to target Day 2 prospects like Carson Beck or Garrett Nussmeier instead of reaching for a quarterback in the first round.
ESPN analyst Mel Kiper Jr. firmly opposes the idea of selecting a quarterback in the first round.
He believes that the 21st overall pick is too valuable to spend on Ty Simpson or any current signal-caller.
Kiper contends that the Steelers should prioritize addressing more pressing needs on their roster before finding a long-term successor to Rodgers, and he suggests that the best strategy for the Steelers is to enhance the protection in front of their quarterback, whoever that may be.
His mock draft specifically highlights Penn State guard Olaivavega Ioane as the optimal choice for the Steelers’ pick.
Standing at 6 feet 4 inches and weighing 320 pounds, Ioane is praised for his combination of impressive power and agile footwork. He views him as a plug-and-play starter who can immediately fill the void left by Isaac Seumalo.
By strengthening their interior offensive line, Pittsburgh can provide a cleaner pocket for a returning veteran while keeping their options open for selecting a developmental quarterback on the second or third day of the draft.
The post Why Mel Kiper isn’t on Ty Simpson train regardless of Steelers’ Aaron Rodgers appeared first on ClutchPoints.
